How to write a Strong Research Proposal
_____________________________________________
I have decided to pen this educational article in response to the numerous requests I have received in my inbox so far from the prospective higher study aspirants. As a requirement of the application process, many schools in the USA asked prospective Ph.D. students to submit a research proposal along with their application materials.
The contents of this writing come from a graduate-level 'Academic Research Writing' course that I took the last Fall. My department requires all of their Ph.D. students to take this course in the first year of their Ph.D. to instill in them the knowledge of academic research writing and set up the stage for their Ph.D. dissertation. This was an exhaustive three credit hours course, and I am presenting a summary of what I have learned in this course. I hope this will be helpful for prospective Ph.D. students, independent researchers, research organizations, and the early career lecturers in our universities.
Attribution: Examples of this writing are adopted from the class materials.
Characteristics of a Strong Research proposal
_________________________________________________
A good research proposal usually has the following characteristics:
Good ideas……Innovative and clear
A concretely defined topic with limited scope
Substance is essential
An engaging and accessible writing style
Clear and concise; no jargon
Building Blocks/Components of a Strong Research Proposal
________________________________________________________________
A strong research proposal comprises of the following five components:
• A captivating and effective title
• The project Summary
• Significance/Intellectual Merit Statement
• Objectives, Hypotheses, and Specific Aims
• Broader Impacts
A captivating and effective title
___________________________________
Your Project title is the most widely distributed and viewed component of your proposal. Various interested people beyond the admission committee (your potential advisor, the other professors in the department) can access this. Because of this possible exposure, you should write a succinct and unambiguous title that captures the most critical features of your work.
An effective title accurately represents the content and scope of the proposal. You should avoid writing a title that tends to be too wordy and either too broad or overblown. If the title is too descriptive, it may convey an impression that your work is narrow! If the title is too broad, the work may appear unfocused and unachievable!
Here are some guidelines for writing an effective title:
1. Present your title in clear, concise phrasing. Eight to twelve words should be sufficient.
2. Avoid jargon and overblown language.
3. Be aware that buzzwords can attract some readers but alienate others.
4. Use professional language to convey the serious nature of your work. Avoid using wording that is humorous or informal.
Compelling titles come in several forms- questions, descriptions, or statements. The most desirable set up for a proposal depends on the specific situation, the proposal's content, the program to which it is submitted, and the type of reviewers who are likely to read the proposal-specialists or generalists. For example, consider the title 'The hydrology of the Santiam River watershed.' This title gives the reader a pretty good idea of the general topic but does not give any details on the system being studied or the questions being asked. On the contrary, the title 'Catastrophic flooding and hill slope activation during droughts in the Santiam River watershed' is more specific and gives the readers the aspects and details of the system being studied.
Below the examples of some titles of successful proposals:
1. 'Analysis of Pesticide Transport Pathways and Degradation in Natural Wetlands.'
2. 'Predicting the Response of Terrestrial Ecosystems to elevated CO2 and climate change.
3. 'Thermal Conductivity in Oceanic Waters: Internal and External Factors'
4. 'Reconciling Molecular and Fossil Evidence on the Age of Angiosperms.'
5. 'Genetics, Mechanism, and Regulation of Protein Synthesis in G. hypothetica'.
Did you notice how brief, clear, and specific those titles are? All of those titles encompass the focus of the study and employ the fundamental concepts of an effective title.
The project Summary
_______________________
The project summary is the first and usually the most critical section in a proposal. This is where you frame the goals and scope of your study, briefly describe your methods, and present your hypotheses and expected results or outputs. A convincing and exciting summary captures the reader's attention and interest and establishes a strong tone for your entire document. Your project summary should also set up proper expectations to engage the reviewer in the Introduction.
Here are some guidelines for writing a compelling project summary:
1. Needs a "snappy" lead sentence to catch the reader's attention. This is where you set up the broader context for the research in the first one or two sentences.
2. Include a discussion of why previous studies have been insufficient to resolve the problem and how your proposal is unique and can remedy the situation. You can address this point by identifying the gaps in the current knowledge and state how your research will fill those gaps or lead the field forward.
3. Explain why your site (or experiment etc.) was chosen for the study.
4. State your research questions as testable hypotheses or, where appropriate, as objectives.
5. In the last few sentences of the paragraph, give a detailed, succinct description of the actual work you will do.
Significance/Intellectual Merit Statement
____________________________________________
The Significance/intellectual Merit is the potential of your study to advance knowledge. An effective, engaging significance section motivates the reviewer to give your proposal a thorough appraisal. The overall goals and significance should be tied to the information in your project summary section and funnels the reader directly to the next section: Objectives, hypotheses, and specific aims. If the significance section is not consistent with the other sections, your proposal will not be persuasive.
Here are some guidelines for writing an effective significance/Intellectual Merit section:
Demonstrate that you have thought about the usage of your findings.
Describe how findings will influence other fields
Describe how findings will challenge or confirm an existing theory or paradigm
Describe how findings will lead to improvements of an existing model.
Objectives, Hypotheses, and Specific Aims
______________________________________________
A clever title, a strong and exciting significance statement, and a well-crafted project summary will be convincing only if the research objectives and tests are carefully constructed, explained clearly, and efficiently organized. If your objectives and tests are ill-conceived, poorly stated, too numerous, or absent altogether, it is unlikely that your proposal will be selected.
Guidelines:
1. You should generally develop your objectives, hypotheses, or specific aims before you begin writing your proposal.
2. If they are still fuzzy, and you find them difficult to explain, then you spend more time refining them.
3. The key aspect of this process is making sure that hypotheses are consistent with the significance statement and linked properly to the objectives.
Objectives, Aims & Hypotheses…how do they differ?
_________________________________________________________
Most novice researchers think that objectives, specific aims, and hypotheses are similar. However, in many ways, they are not! It would help if you understood the differences and functions of each so that you know how and when to use them.
Objectives – objectives are usually broad, scientifically far-reaching aspects of a study. Sometimes they verge on significance statements. They typically leave the reader to beg for more specifics about "how" to address the issue?
Examples:
1. To further our understanding of how global climate might affect the freshwater-lake plankton communities.
2. To lead to more informed policy decisions about the effects of electromagnetic radiations on humans residing near high voltage power lines.
3. To understand how cell division and differentiation are regulated by extracellular and intracellular signals.
Did you notice those statements leave the reviewer to search for more specifics about 'how to address the issue?
Specific Aims- Specific aims focus on a particular question or hypotheses and the method or tasks necessary to address the question. These are activities and should read like the "headlines" for each methods section.
Examples:
1. We will determine the crystal structure of all six minerals in the source block.
2. We will establish the differences in temperatures and humidity among sites over time.
3. We will determine whether the organism promotes biofilm formation by secreting an inhibitory compound.
Can you see how questions or hypotheses could be constructed to accomplish the aims?
Hypotheses –Hypotheses are testable conjectures that address a specific aim or question. Well-stated hypotheses lead directly to experiments that form the basis of the research project. Often these lead to a particular set of experiments.
Examples:
1. Lead is complexed by a chelating agent associated with adventitious roots, transported across the membrane, and stored in the inner cortex.
2. Channel roughness is greater, and velocity, stream power, and shear stress are lower in restored reaches versus unrestored reaches.
3. Zinc can displace other metals on enzyme-active sites.
Is it obvious how these lead to a specific set of experiments?
Broader Impacts
__________________
Broader impacts are the potential of your study to benefit society and contribute to the achievement of specific, desired societal outcomes. You must ensure that your proposal addresses the following broader impacts criterion as many as possible:
1. How well does the activity advance discovery and understanding while promoting teaching, training, and learning?
2. How well does the proposed activity broaden the participation of underrepresented groups (e.g., gender, ethnicity, disability, geographic, etc.)?
3. To what extent will it enhance the infrastructure for research and education, such as facilities, instrumentation, networks, and partnerships?
4. Will the results be disseminated broadly to enhance scientific and technological understanding?
5. What may be the proposed activity's benefit to society?
Disclaimer: Admins can compile and save this post as a file for reference for future readers. You can share this article with proper attribution and credit. Thank you.
Writer
Rana Dey