How US evaluates your application

 American Graduate Admission Process: From an insider’s point of view

______________________________________________________________________

Disclaimer and Attribution: 


The core crux of this writing is adopted from the rubrics and criterion established by the graduate admission committee of the University of California-Davis. Since, the contents of this writing directly come from the graduate admission committee of a decent school, without the loss of generality, it can be taken as a recipe for preparing your application materials for grad school. The scope of the writing can be fairly applicable to a broad range of disciplines ranging from Arts and Humanities, Applied and Natural Sciences, Business Studies, and Engineering. Due to the stochastic and holistic nature of the American graduate admission process, readers are advised to apply the recipe with a pinch of salt! 


American Graduate Admission Process: 

__________________________________________

The American Graduate Admission Process is perhaps the most random and less well constrained. Contrary to the European and Australian schools, which typically operate on the student’s academic accomplishments, American schools rather employ a holistic rubric while evaluating the applications. Those rubrics include (but not limited to): Students' GPA, Test Scores, Application Essays, and Recommendations. Due to the closure of the testing locations, and the testing difficulties posed by the COVID Pandemic, almost all the American graduate programs waived/didn’t require the Graduate Record Exam (GRE) score (they may reinstate this requirement later).  Considering the large pool of applicants, and the relative uncertainties posed by the pandemic, it is therefore customary to identify and ascribe the heavyweight components contributing to the selection process. The purpose of this writing to present a synthesis of the information that I cached over the years and give the prospective students a clearer and authentic view of the Post COVID American Graduate admission process. So, without further ado let’s dive in: 


Grading Rubrics

__________________

As mentioned before, the American Graduate Application process is holistic, meaning your application will be viewed as a whole as it pertains to the relative strengths and weakness of the application materials. Almost all the applications submitted to the graduate school are gone through the following deciding rubrics: 


Rubric 1: Whether Student is persistent and adaptable? 

Reasoning: The graduate student experience can involve a range of challenges.

How you can address this: Describe an example of how you demonstrated resilience and/or perseverance in the pursuit of your academic goals or in your personal life and how you have grown as a result. For instance, if you are the 1st gen student (in your family) going to pursue a graduate degree, belonging to an immigrant family, coming from a background of socio-economic disadvantages, you can highlight those issues in your essay and demonstrate how you excelled and grown as a result. 


Rubric 2: Whether Student is motivated to pursue scientific research? 

Reasoning: It is important for researchers to stay curious and be willing to question their own and other’s work in the pursuit of great science.

How you can address this: Please describe a time when you worked on something you were excited about, either academic or personal, in which you exhibited these qualities. If you have had the opportunity to conduct your own research, this would be a great time to tell them about it. Express your curiosity, love of problem-solving, commitment to learning while describing this. Please be as specific and descriptive as possible.


Rubric 3: Whether Student has taken advantage of (or made) opportunities in seeking out research experiences? 

Reasoning: Taking Charge of your studies will help you to achieve your goals

How you can address this: Please describe a time when you worked in your university’s research organizations. If you have participated in national or international research competition, this would be a great time to tell them about it.


Rubric 4: Whether student’s interests are genuine and well-rounded? 

Reasoning: Great science takes time. So, it is important for researchers to stay focused and motivated. 

How you can address this: What brings you to pursue Graduate study (be honest with yourself)? Application committees are looking for evidence that you are passionate about the discipline, and why a research-based graduate degree will help you to achieve your goals.


Rubric 5 

a) Whether Student can work well independently and is self-directed? 

How you can address this: Application committees are looking for a description of projects or actions taken on their own initiative either in or out of academics

b) Whether Student works well with others and responds well to constructive feedback?

How you can address this: Please describe a time when you demonstrated leadership, or contribution to shared or team goals. 


Rubric 6: Whether Student’s preparation, experiences, and interests match the specific resources and characteristics of the graduate program? 

How you can address this: Describe a specific topic of research that you could pursue at this school. This topic need not become the actual topic of your thesis research, but please describe why you think the program you are applying is specifically well suited to support such research. Please identify specific faculty within your desired graduate program with whom you would like to work and how their interests match your own.


Rubric 7: Whether Student’s Academic record includes appropriate coursework and level of competence to build from for graduate-level research in expressed subdiscipline?  

How you can address this: Application committees are looking for topic-specific foundational coursework (geo/earth/env sci., math, physics, chem, bio), breadth and challenging coursework, UG and Grad GPA, research projects. For instance, for Engineering Applicants, make a document listing all of your relevant coursework in relevant fields (math, physics, chemistry) and upload this as supplement material. 


Rubric 8: Whether Student communicates in a clear, organized, and logical manner? 

How you can address this: Please be specific and clear while you addressing those rubrics. Make logical connections in your writing. Maintain a formal and neutral tone (you can be appreciative in times) while describing your specific aims and research. Don’t be too fancy and avoid unnecessary details that add up nothing. 


Scoring  

________

The above-mentioned rubrics are scored on a scale of 1 to 4. The description of the scores are as follows: 

Score of 1: Unsatisfactory

Meaning: Little evidence of this skill or cognitive ability, or evidence to the contrary. 


Score of 2: Developing

Meaning: Minimal evidence or only in the early stages


Score of 3: Competent

Meaning: Sufficient evidence with some examples or points that clearly attest to a high level of preparation or achievement in this area


Score of 4: Exemplary

Meaning: Strong evidence which meets all expectations for preparation for graduate school


Overall Ranking and Verdict 

______________________________

The scores of each individual rubrics are weighted and averaged to calculate the final cumulative score and based on that score a grade will assign to that. A description of the grades is given below: 


Grade A+: A cumulative score of 4.0 

Meaning: Exceptional application on all metrics. 

Verdict: Recruit! 


Grade A: A cumulative score of 3.5 to 4.0 

Meaning: Strong application with evidence addressing and supporting all metrics. 

Verdict: Recruit!


Grade B: A cumulative score of 3.0 to 3.5

Meaning: Potentially admissible, but there is evidence missing for one more metric, that would need to be addressed when starting in the graduate program. Potential advisors need to address how these metrics can be addressed. 

Verdict: Waitlist! 


Grade C: A cumulative score below 3.0

Meaning: Lacking evidence on multiple metrics; inappropriate background or coursework preparation for expressed topic of study; expressed topics of interest have no overlap with potential mentors in our program. 

Verdict: Deny application! 


Note Before: The above-described rubrics, gradings, and verdicts are published by the graduate admission committee of UC Davis. The purpose of this writing is to give the prospective graduate students an idea of how their applications will be reviewed so that they can focus and address the specific rubrics as concerned. You can share this article on any platform with proper attribution and courtesy. Thanks.

0 Comentarios